Friend of our site


MMA Headlines


UFC HP


Josh Gross


MMA Fighting


MMA Torch


MMA Weekly


Sherdog (News)


Sherdog (Articles)


Lowkick


Liver Kick


Caged In


MMA Junkie


MMA Mania


Bloody Elbow


Fightlinker


Fightnomics


MMA Ratings


Rating Fights


MMA Convert


Fightline


Fight Medicine


CompuStrike


MMA Frenzy


Fighters


MMA Betting


Search this site



Latest Articles


News Corner


MMA Rising


Audio Corner


Oddscast


MMA Dude Bro


Sherdog Radio


The Fightworks Podcast


Eddie Goldman


Pro MMA Radio


MMA Torch


Video Corner


Fight Hub


The Fight Nerd


Special thanks to...

Link Rolodex

Site Index


To access our list of posting topics and archives, click here.

Friend of our site


Buy and sell MMA photos at MMA Prints

Site feedback


Fox Sports: "Zach Arnold's Fight Opinion site is one of the best spots on the Web for thought-provoking MMA pieces."

Site Meter

« | Home | »

ESPN’s brutal weight cutting video package demonstrates the incompetence of the fight industry

By Zach Arnold | March 20, 2017

Print Friendly and PDF

Sandwiched in-between wall-to-wall coverage of the NCAA March Madness basketball tournament, ESPN decided to air a video package on Cris Cyborg and her brutal adventures in weight-cutting. It was built upon this video feature Cyborg put online several months ago about her torturous experience of dehydrating herself to the point where blood could not be drawn from her arm:

The video package itself was not entirely new but it was updated by ESPN to contain some interesting responses to its initial airing.

ESPN aired Cyborg’s claim that UFC refused to give her a fight at 145 pounds and that allegedly UFC made a u-turn on 145 pound fights when they found out about the Outside the Lines segment. Whether that is factually accurate or an issue of false light, I cannot say one way or the other. The segment claims that Cyborg rejected the offer of a 145 pound title fight and aired her various comments talking about how insulted she was that someone 0-2 was going to get a UFC 145 pound title shot. This drew an analogous response from Dana White saying that players for the New England Patriots don’t get to pick and choose when they participate in a title game.

Added to the context to the weight cutting issue was Cyborg’s recent USADA back-and-forth over a diuretic and whether she had properly gotten doctor’s permission to use it.

Andy Foster planted his flag in the ground to try to stop bad weight cuts

California State Athletic Commission Executive Officer Andy Foster has made it a mission to try to put a stop to the kind of massive weight cuts in boxing and MMA that have damaged kidney & organ function of fighters who knew better but decided to take the risk no matter what the price was to pay for such destructive, masochistic behavior.

California pushed the idea of early weigh-ins. Instead of making weight at the last minute, weigh-ins are taking place at 10 AM the day before a show and the traditional weigh-in events with fans are ceremonial in nature. The idea, which is entirely logical and reasonable on its face, was to give fighters more time to hydrate so that they wouldn’t be in such bad shape come fight time. Plus, if a fighter fails to make weight at 10 AM, there is always the opportunity for a promoter to negotiate a last minute replacement to save a fight card.

What appeared to be solid policy has backfired in a disastrous manner. More fighters are missing weight. More fighters are turning down last-minute opponents. Promoters are pissed. Fighters are extra pissed, not only at opponents for missing weight but for how much promoters are allegedly paying them (or not) in terms of show money. See: Tony Ferguson.

The carrot didn’t work, so bring out the stick

That’s the best way to summarize the newest policy evolution by Andy Foster and the state of California regarding punishment of fighters who miss weight.

Remember the days of “shower bonuses” under Lorenzo Fertitta? California is now pushing for a new policy on their bout contracts to require, I suspect under penalty of perjury, disclosure regarding potential win bonuses. If a fighter misses weight, they already lose 20% of their purse but they can still fight the next day and win both base money and bonus money. The new California policy would attack not only the base money but would also take a percentage of the win bonus.

I believe this will actually create an adverse impact and make the weight cutting situation even worse in California-regulated combat sports.

First, I expect managers, promoters, and fighters to try to hide any oral or written contractual bonus clauses and dare the Athletic Commission to administratively hound them with the Attorney General’s office for punishment. If the penalty for perjury isn’t criminal in nature, why are people in the fight business going to care?

Second, I would expect bonus agreements to go off the books. It’s hard enough to pry financial information honestly out of event participants. If this becomes too much of a headache for UFC, what’s to stop UFC from blowing their whistle and proclaiming win bonuses to be part of their contractual trade secrets that should be legally sealed?

Third, there isn’t enough money to be made for the majority of fighters to change their behavior by fining them. You can’t half-ass the punishment here. If you’re going to drop the hammer, drop the hammer and start suspending fighters the way you suspend fighters for doping. The threat of fining fighters for weight cutting will likely turn out to be mostly for show. Fighters want to fight. Take away their ability to fight the same way you get an athlete’s attention by telling them to sit down.

There is no easy answer on addressing the incredible dilemma of weight cutting. Changing weight classes in increments of 10 pounds per division is really where everything is heading. Until the fans and promoters agree to acquiesce to those changes, everyone is spinning their wheels and more fighters are going to end up in the hospital due to kidney failure.

Topics: Boxing, CSAC, MMA, Media, UFC, Zach Arnold | 6 Comments » | Permalink | Trackback |

6 Responses to “ESPN’s brutal weight cutting video package demonstrates the incompetence of the fight industry”

  1. Caster says:

    The BBC Three program “Extraordinary Bodies” did a great episode on MMA weight cuts.

    “Weight Cut – Can I Lose 10% Of My Body Weight Overnight? | Extreme MMA”

    https://youtu.be/t_FO7MzAnzM

  2. Diaz's packed bowl says:

    I didn’t watch that video(cyborg is just too ugly) theres another video about cutting, but I predicted more problems with the early weigh ins.

    Adding more weight classes will NOT do anything to eliminate heavy cutting.
    One championships has the solution move everyone up one weight class and I suggest add a cruiser weight. Since most 205 lb fighters are about 220. And DJ’s division is too small to find any real contenders.

    We have all seen the improved performances by Cowboy Johny and Kelvin. They look better sound better and fight better and they still cut up to 10 lbs.

    Figure out every fighters fat to muscle ratios, get their hi to low weight swings and move them up. Give all fighters a directive to stay within 10 lbs of their weight class so they won’t need to cut more than 10 lbs in one night.
    A 10 lb cut is no problem. Heavyweight fighters can loose 10 lbs during an actual fight just by sweating.
    Maybe 8 lbs for LW and below…

  3. [...] Breakdown: The #1 Thing All Black Belts Have In Common? Gracie Barra: 3 Mistakes BJJ Students Make Fight Opinion: ESPN Weight Cutting Video Demonstrates Incompetence Of Fight Industry BJJ Brick: Episode 179 Pedro Sauer 8Th Degree Coral Belt Show The Art Podcast: #107 – Marvin [...]

  4. Rob Maysey says:

    Curious focal point Zach.

    The power is held by the promoters–virtually all. Fighters who refuse to fight with a “penalty assessed” (with part or all going to the AC) face professional consequences.

    To curb the problem–the AC’s need to start cancelling fights. Do not allow the fighters to “accept” the bouts.

    Bouts have been approved where Rogan–throughout the “bout” declares the opponent is LHW in a Welterweight bout.

    This is not acceptable.

    The ABC proposal regarding weight classes needs to be overwhelmingly supported–promoters be damned. One promoter killed this proposal in 2008. http://www.fightline.com/fl-news-2008-0707-330159-/

    The MMAFA supports the ABC in this proposal, and further, believes that hydration or other further testing is necessary to ensure that fighters are fighting at healthy weights.

    http://forum.mmajunkie.com/forum/threads/california-athletic-commission-proposed-new-weight-classes-abc-votes-august.68021/

    Good stuff as always Zach.

    Rob Maysey

  5. Chris says:

    I go with “dropping the hammer”. Suspend fighters for not making weight.

  6. 45 Huddle says:

    For the UFC… weight cutting should be monitored for an entire week before the fight. They could basically eliminate weight cutting if done properly.

Comments

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture.
Anti-spam image